Anthony Shaia, DDS
Dr. Anthony Shaia graduated from The Ohio State University Dental School in 2000. He completed a General Practice Residency at Miami Valley Hospital, and he has received advanced training in training in implant dentistry, laser dentistry, and IV conscious sedation. Prior to attending dental school, Dr. Shaia attended St. Ignatius High School and John Carroll University, where he earned a bachelors degree in biology. While he has been practicing dentistry for over 20 years, he remains committed to regularly furthering his education in the dental field. Dr. Shaia is dedicated to providing our patients with the highest quality of dentistry and he works hard to make their experience as comfortable and painless as possible. He has a true passion for dentistry that motivates him to continually strive for better, newer techniques.
Dr. Shaia is married, and his wife, also a dentist, is part of the Shaia Dental Care team. They have a son and a daughter, and he is a dedicated father who actively supports their sports and hobbies. He enjoys coaching and teaching new skills, keeping the family busy with fun and meaningful activities. Dr Shaia’s hobbies include golfing, fantasy football, skiing, and spending time with his family.
Crystel Shaia, DDS
Dr. Crystel is Dr. Shaia’s wife and a proud member of the Shaia Dental Care team. She graduated as Valedictorian of her dental school class in 2009 and went on to complete her residency at St. Elizabeth Hospital in Youngstown, Ohio. She has a special passion for endodontics and is known for her gentle touch and attention to detail. She has a natural way with children, and young patients love seeing her, as she makes every visit comfortable and positive.
When she’s not caring for patients, Dr. Crystel enjoys skiing, swimming, and traveling. She also treasures time spent with her family, especially cheering on her children in their many activities and adventures.
Meet Our Team
At Shaia Dental Care, our team is committed to providing you with an exceptional dental experience. Every member of our team is caring, educated, skilled, and friendly. We work hard to ensure that your visit is comfortable and pleasant. To learn more about us and Dr. Anthony Shaia, our dentist in Middleburg Heights and Middleburg Heights, Ohio, we welcome you to call or visit our office today. We look forward to caring for you!
Kayla – Dental Office ManagerKayla joined our team in August of 2021. She started her dental career in 2015 after getting her dental assisting and radiology degree. Kayla loves every aspect of her job, from meeting the patients initially and getting to know them personally, to helping them understand their insurance benefits, all while making sure they are getting scheduled for the treatment they need and deserve. Kayla loves the family aspect of Shaia Dental care. We laugh and joke, but also keep our patients care our first priority always. In her free time Kayla likes to exercise, travel, and spend time withfamily and friends.
Olivia – Dental Receptionist
Olivia joined the Shaia Dental Care team in April 2025, bringing over five years of experience as a nurse’s assistant. She combines her passion for patient care with her warm, welcoming personality. She loves greeting patients as soon as they walk in, meeting new faces, and catching up with our established patients. Her favorite part of the job is seeing the smiles on our patients’ faces after completing their treatment with Dr. Shaia. Olivia truly considers the Shaia Dental Care team to be like family. Outside of work, she enjoys hiking and swimming with her two golden retrievers, painting, reading, and playing both guitar and piano.
Kaitlyn – Dental AssistantKaitlyn joined our team in March of 2021. She has been assisting since 2014, graduating from Cuyahoga Community College. She is licensed in radiology and certified in CPR, along with the use of AED. Kaitlyn is passionate about dental and enjoys helping our patients feel comfortable. She says this practice is “simply the best” and “loves our team!”Away from the office, Kaitlyn is a wife and mom of two boys, whom she adores. In her free time, she enjoys to play volleyball and video games.
Destiny – Dental AssistantDestiny joined our team in May 2019. She is a graduate of Normandy High School and the valedictorian of her dental assisting class. She is a certified Ohio dental assistant. She is licensed in radiology and certified in CPR and in the use of AED. Destiny loves the friendly and inviting atmosphere at Shaia Dental Care and does her best to make sure that every patient is comfortable. Destiny ensures that our office is not only a safe and sterile environment but also a friendly and supportive one. She always puts our patients first and makes sure that their needs are addressed. In her free time Destiny enjoys taking care of her cats and plants.
Shauna – Registered Dental HygienistIn May 2018, Shauna joined our team and loves being part of a practice that has a positive, well-structured work environment and such great co-workers! Shauna graduated from Cuyahoga Community College in 2014. She was on the Dean’s list and a member of the Phi Theta Kappa Honor Society. Getting to know patients is one of her favorite parts of her work day, and she loves seeing their oral health improve. Shauna contributes to the success of our practice by personalizing each patient’s dental appointment based on their needs. She tries her best to accommodate everyone and make them feel relaxed while being as thorough and gentle as possible. Shauna was a dental assistant before becoming a licensed hygienist. In her free time, Shauna enjoys exercising, including yoga, Pilates, tennis, bike riding and swimming. She also loves to read and try new restaurants!
Crystal – Registered Dental Hygienist (Part Time)Crystal has been a part of Dr Shaia’s team since 2017! She has been a dental hygienist since 2005. Crystal’s favorite part about our office is working alongside a great dental team. She loves getting to know the patients and helping them keep their mouths healthy. Her favorite thing to do when not working is spend time with her family.
Kayla – Registered Dental Hygienist (Part Time)Kayla has been in the dental field since 2011. Starting as a dental assistant, she gained experience in many aspects of dentistry including; general dentistry, orthodontics, endodontics and periodontics. Her passion for periodontics lead her to becoming a dental hygienist in June of 2019. She loves being part of the practice because it feels like a family! Getting to educate patients and relate overall health with dental health is one of her favorite parts of being a dental hygienist. Kayla contributes to the success of our practice by tailoring each patient’s visit to their needs and learning about them on a personal level. In her free time, Kayla enjoys baking, painting, and spending time with family as well as traveling to new places.